A battleship starts moving at 12pm from an integer point on the real line with constant speed, landing on every hour again on an integer point. Every day at midnight you can shoot at an arbitrary point on the real plane, trying to destroy the battleship. Can you find a strategy with which you will eventually succeed to do this?


If we know the starting point of the battleship and its speed, then we can determine its position at any time after 12pm.

There are countably many combinations (X, Y) of starting point and speed. We can order them in the following way:

(0, 0) - starting point 0, speed 0;
(0, 1) - starting point 0, speed +1;
(1, 0) - starting point 1, speed 0;
(0, -1) - starting point 0, speed -1;
(1, 1) - starting point 1, speed +1;
(-1, 0) - starting point -1, speed 0;
(0, 2) - starting point 0, speed +2;
(1, -1) - starting point 1, speed -1;
(-1, 1) - starting point -1, speed 1;
(2, 0)- starting point 2, speed 0,
and so on. Of course, we can choose the ordering in many different ways.

Now we can start exhausting all possibilities one after another. First we assume the combination is (0, 0), calculate where the battleship would be at midnight during the first day and shoot there. Then we assume the combination is (0, 1), calculate where the battleship would be at midnight during the second day and shoot there. If we continue like this, eventually we will hit the battleship.