Donuts and Candies

Huey has 3 donuts, Dewey has 5 donuts. Louie comes along and three of them split the donuts equally. In exchange, Louie offers 8 candies to Huey and Dewey. What is the fair way to split the candies?

Huey must take 1 chocolate, and Dewey must take 7. This is because each of them ate 8/3 donuts, and therefore Huey gave away 1/3 of a donut, whereas Dewey gave away 7/3 of a donut.

+ latest posts

We do not know where this puzzle originated from. If you have any information, please let us know via email.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Not quite. Huey gave away 1/3 of A doughnut, not 1/3 of his doughnuts, which would be 1 doughnut. Similarly Dewey did not and could not have given away 7/3 of his doughnuts, for that is more than he could possess. Dewey gave away 2 and a third doughnuts. Despite this misdescription of what happened, the answer as to the distribution of the candies (then changed to chocolate – a candy need not contain chocolate) is correct.